“It’s Up to You,” a charming and wistful ballad released in 1957, is a quintessential example of Ricky Nelson’s early rock and roll sound. Nelson, born Eric Hilliard Nelson in 1940, rose to fame not only as a teen idol singer but also as a star on his family’s popular television show, “The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet.” This platform provided him with invaluable exposure, launching his musical career almost instantaneously. He was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1987, solidifying his lasting impact on the genre. While “It’s Up to You” may not have topped the charts in the same way as some of his later hits like “Poor Little Fool,” it still resonated deeply with audiences and contributed to the growing popularity of Nelson’s wholesome yet subtly rebellious image.
The song itself is a heartfelt plea, where Nelson vulnerably lays his emotions bare, placing the future of the relationship entirely in the hands of his love interest. Lyrics like “It’s up to you, to be my girl / I want you, more than anything in this world” paint a picture of sincere longing and vulnerability, a common theme resonating with the often emotionally charged experiences of teenage romance. Listeners at the time responded positively to the song’s sincerity and relatable lyrics, praising Nelson’s smooth vocals and the song’s catchy melody. While critics weren’t always kind to Nelson’s seemingly manufactured image, fans embraced his accessible charm and genuine delivery, making “It’s Up to You” another stepping stone in his successful career. The song continues to be appreciated today for its classic 1950s sound and its honest portrayal of young love.