“It’s Up to You,” released in 1957, is a quintessential example of the teen idol sound that defined Ricky Nelson’s early career. Ricky Nelson, born Eric Hilliard Nelson, was more than just a singer; he was a television star, acting alongside his family in the popular sitcom “The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet.” This platform catapulted him to fame, allowing his musical career to flourish alongside his acting. Nelson was a key figure in the transition from early rock and roll to the more polished, teen-friendly sounds of the late 1950s and early 1960s. He charted numerous hits throughout his career, consistently landing in the Billboard Top 100. While “It’s Up to You” didn’t reach the absolute pinnacle of the charts, it solidified Nelson’s position as a heartthrob and demonstrated his ability to connect with a youthful audience.
The song itself explores the familiar themes of young love and uncertainty. The lyrics paint a picture of a young man placing his romantic fate entirely in the hands of the object of his affection. He’s hesitant, unsure of the girl’s feelings, and explicitly states that the decision to pursue a relationship rests solely with her – “It’s up to you to say if you want me to stay.” This vulnerable and somewhat passive stance resonated deeply with teenage listeners at the time.
Audience reception to “It’s Up to You” was generally positive. The song’s catchy melody and Nelson’s smooth vocals made it a radio favorite. Many appreciated the relatable sentiment of the lyrics, capturing the anxieties and uncertainties inherent in young relationships. While some critics might have dismissed it as lightweight pop, the song’s enduring appeal speaks to its ability to capture a specific moment in time and resonate with the emotions of a particular generation. “It’s Up to You” remains a beloved track for fans of Ricky Nelson and a testament to the power of simple, heartfelt songwriting.