“It’s Up to You,” a classic from 1957, is a quintessential example of Ricky Nelson’s early rock and roll sound. Ricky Nelson, born Eric Hilliard Nelson in 1940, was a teen idol who seamlessly transitioned from television stardom on “The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet,” where he often performed musically, to a successful recording career. He represented a smoother, more polished brand of rockabilly that appealed to a wider audience than some of his more rebellious contemporaries. While not always topping the charts with every release, Nelson consistently landed songs in the Billboard Top 100, establishing himself as a prominent figure in the emerging rock and roll scene. He was later inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1987.
“It’s Up to You” perfectly captures the anxieties and uncertainties of young love. The lyrics portray a hesitant suitor putting the ball entirely in the object of his affection’s court. He’s confessed his feelings but emphasizes that the future of the relationship rests on her decision. The song’s simplicity and earnest delivery resonated strongly with teenagers experiencing similar romantic dilemmas, reflecting the vulnerability and dependence on reciprocal affection that characterized young relationships.
Upon its release, the song found considerable popularity, contributing to Nelson’s burgeoning fame. While specific chart details are difficult to pinpoint decades later without in-depth historical databases, it certainly added to his string of hits. Feedback at the time, as reflected in period magazine articles and fan accounts, suggests that “It’s Up to You” was praised for its relatable lyrics and Nelson’s charming vocal delivery. It solidified his image as the sensitive, approachable heartthrob, a persona that continued to define his career for years to come. The song continues to be remembered as a sweet and innocent snapshot of teenage romance from the golden age of rock and roll.